This review is reproduced without permission.
Weight Price Setup Lighting Adjust Stab Tank Time Maint Dura Overall
ment ility Boil Time enance bility
Camping Gaz 470 HP
Burner: 10oz $37.95 4.5 4.5 4 3 2:15:00 3 4 3.5
Full cart: 2lb, 1oz w/ piezo ignition $53.95 0:4:30-0:7:15
HI: simple, hot, inexpensive canisters LO: poor flame adjustment, unstable, no windscreen
Epigas 3009 HP
Burner: 12oz $34.95 4.5 5 5 3 1:57:15 3.5 4.5 4.5
Full 250 cart: 1lb, 9oz w/ piezo ignition $54.95 0:4:30
3.5oz cart. $3.95
7.5oz cart. $4.95
15.5oz cart. $8.95
HI: convenient, powerful, good system compatibility LO: expensive cartridges, no windscreen
MSR Whisperlite
Burner: w/pump & $58.00 3 3 3 4.5 4:12:00 5 4.5 4.5
screens: 13oz includes tools, pump, 0:4:30
w/full 22 oz screen, storage bag
bottle: Fuel bottles:
2lb, 11oz. $6.50 - $8.50
HI: powerful, durable, field maintainable LO: difficult priming, poor flame control
Optimus Hunter
Empty: 1lb, 10oz $90.95 4 2 3 2 1:29:00 3.5 4.5 2.5
Full: 2lb 0:6:30-0:12:15
HI: durable, simple, spare parts available LO: prime-dependent, noisy, unstable
Peak 1 Apex II
Empty: 1lb, 8oz $65.85 3.5 3 3.5 4 3:30:30 2 3 4
Full: 2lb w/bottle. 4:15-5:15
Screen: $6.20
Maintenance Kit: $13.00
Kero Generator: $7.00
HI: hot, simmers well, quiet LO: complex, bulky, soft metal
Sigg Fire-Jet
Burner: 1lb, 3oz $92.00 4 3.5 3 4 6:05:30 4 3.5 4
1 liter fuel: 2lb, 8oz Fuel bottles: 0:9:45
1.5 liter - $7.75
3.0 liter - $10.50
HI: simple, stable, innovative LO: won't simmer, fragile fuel tube, moderate heat
Trangia 27-5
Burner: 1lb, 1oz $70.00 4.5 4 2.5 4.5 1:34:15 4.5 4.5 3.5
w/pots & gripper: 2lb 0:18:00-0:26:30
HI: packable system, great cookware LO: poor heat, no flame adjustment, short burn time
Zip Ztove Backpacker
Stove: 1lb $54.00 5 3 2 3 0:10:00 2 3.5 3.5
w/pot & screen:1lb, 10oz 0:7:15-0:21:00
HI: packable system, low fuel cost, hot LO: burns wet fuel poorly, poor repairability, requires tinkering
Setup considers how easy it was to get the stove assembled and filled using half-frozen fingers.
Lighting assesses how easy each stove was to coax to life, including priming, pumping, and general futzing around.
Adjustment measures ease of flame control and whether you'd char your fingerprints off fiddling with knobs.
Stability rates the hazard potential of balancing a large pot in a crowded tent vestibule or on a sloping site.
Boil Time states amount of time to boil a quart of water, from pan set-down to lid_blowing boilover on a heated and full-blast stove.
Tank Time measures fuel longevity from beginning of prime to flame disappearance, using manufacturer's recommended fill limits.
Maintenance judges scope and ease of field repair, cleaning, and part replacement.
Durability assesses whether such maintenance might be likely, and takes into account bending, denting, parts-loss, and projected life span.
Overall Subjective impression separate from the other parameters - not an average. Assets like compactness, convenience, and trail packaging figures heavily here.