
The following is a series of discussion about guns from knowledgeable
persons which I have collected for your interest.  1996

Subject: Re: The All-Purpose Carbine
Date: Mon, 30 Oct 1995 01:20:43 GMT

Microsoft Network is hereby prohibited from retransmitting any of this
message in any way, shape, or form.

Thompson Contender Rifles (TCR-83 & TCR-87) are still available on 
the used market. How about selecting 4 barrels like: 12 gauge, .22 LR,
223, and .308. For carbine purposes have barrels of 16" or go with a
25" barrel for your long range gun. One receiver accepts all the above
barrels. This makes for a light weight, accurate, yet versatile single
shot rifle / carbine/ or shotgun.

Yep, and Murphy guarantees that you'll have the wrong barrel on it
when you need to take a shot. And Murphy guarantees it'll be the
receiver that breaks if anything does, leaving you without a functional
firearm at all. If you want 4 single shots, buy 4 single shots. At
least you'll have redundancy on your side. But since bolt repeaters
don't cost much more, or weigh much more, than a single shot, why
not take advantage of having that immediate backup round?

Also, TC won't sell you a .308 barrel. They claim the receiver isn't
strong enough to handle it. One of the aftermarket barrel makers will
sell you a .308 barrel for the TC, but he won't warrantee it.

I still have lingering doubts about reliability, despite all that I hear.

A well set-up rifle shooting correct ammo is very reliable. Large 
grain ammo that doesn't burn clean is what got a lot of our boys 
killed in Vietnam. So ammo selection is the key to reliability.

Actually, you've got that backwards. Stoner specified IMR stick
powders, but DOD put the contract out to use ball powder. That
caused more fouling in the small bore, but it was really the
lack of instruction received by the troops on the extra care 
and cleaning that the small bore weapon needed than the M14 that 
most of them had trained on in Basic that got them in trouble.

The first time many troops saw the M16 was when they got off
the plane in Vietnam. It turned out to be fatally expensive 
on the job training for many of them.

 And finally, I'm a college student (an undergrad, no less),
and more than $400 for a rifle is a _REAL_ stretch. (Not that less 
than  $400 is chump change). If I can only afford one firearm, and 
only have room to store one, I figure that I'd best find one that I 
can legally hunt with.

Don't know the laws in Kansas. They're legal some places, not 
others. In Penn., for instance, no semi-auto firearm is legal for 
hunting. And mag capacity is another consideration. Many states 
limit you to 3 rounds or so. So you've got a good point there, for sure.

BUT in a _survival_ situation, Damn legality!!! You do what you 
have to do to get by and stay alive, period!

Sure, but train like you fight, fight like you trained. If you
don't use the weapon in training, IE legal hunts now, how do
you expect to use it proficiently in survival situations later?

You'll almost always do better with a weapon with which you have
great familiarity, and in which you have great confidence, than
you will with an ostensibly superior arm with which you have no
practical experience.

When the excrement hits the air impeller is not the time
to be learning how to use an unfamiliar weapon.

In another thread, there was some mention of the characteristics
of the "ideal" all-purpose carbine. I was thinking of giving that topic
a thread all of its own.

I was thinking of a rifle, bolt or lever action, capable of
dropping man- or deer-sized targets out to ~200 meters, in either
a .22 center-fire or .30 caliber, lightweight, and in a readily available
caliber.

 While not popular with some folks I like to vote for my M-1 carbine. It's 
light , Accurate to 200 yds, Power to kill Deer or man (with good loads 
and shot placement),readily available, simple to operate, & .30 caliber.

My second choice would a lever action Winchester or Marlin 30-30 or maybe
a Ruger auto rifle. While some others have their own ideas, these are mine.
Bye bye !
                                                                       
 "WHEN A MAN WITH A WINCHESTER MEETS A MAN WITH A .45,
THE MAN WITH RIFLE WINS."  

My money goes to the Russian SKS @ $100 cant beat it on price.
Great fit & Finish. easy to load ammo and SCADS of spare parts
 that are easy to buy of fabricate (For you basement machinists out there!)

I figure that the ideal gun for whatever purpose is the one that you:

A) Feel most confident in.
B) Feel most comfortable toting around.
C) Shoot the best with.

Not necessarily in that order

And, if I might add,

D) The one you *HAVE WITH YOU* when you really need it!
The gun you left at home won't do you any good.

 * QMPro 1.53 * Political Correctness:  a marketing term for mind control.


 I've seen a few advertisements for an M-1 carbine reworked to 
 shoot. 45 Win mag. If the thing actually works and shoots accurately 
 enough(and you have a good supply of ammo or components),it might be 
 the ticket out to 100,150 yards.

I've heard about these, and considered having it done do a "junker"
carbine.  However, I heard a couple of years ago that there was
a problem with these converted carbines coming apart after they'd
been used for a while (the details escape me).

It could be that there was a problem early on, and that they've
gotten it right by now -- but I'd want to hear from several
people who'd been doing a lot of shooting with converted carbines
before going for one myself.

I have and use both an M1 Carbine and
an SKS and would recommend either one.

Both use cheap readily available ammo
and you can get replacement magazines that are legal

In response. If others find that the AR-15 or the SKS or whatever are
the ideal weapons for their individual situations, that's their choice.

I use an SKS carbine, personally - China-made w/ the only addition being 
a 20-round fixed mag my wife asked for (she prefers the original stock).  

I originally bought it because it was cheap, fired a fair-sized commonly 
available bullet, has a decent mag capacity, is semi-auto, and is a 
military pattern that has been in service for close to fifty years.  I 
went shooting last month for the first time in nearly a year.

I surprised myself - I managed to consistently hit a railroad tie-plate 
(about 6" square) at 100 yards.  Wifey liked it so much she claimed it 
as hers and told me to find myself another rifle.  I have my eye on a 
bolt-action .308 military surplus rifle this time - oughta give me a bit 
more range for hunting. 
  
just my $0.02
    
A thought on specialization (in rifles).

A lot of people prefer a bolt action for hunting, but a semi-automatic
for self defense.  I remember thinking, that if I had a bolt action rifle
and a semi-automatic rifle (in the same caliber), and I was going out
to hunt, and there was even the least chance of needing a rifle for self 
defense, that I would take the semi-auto.  The bolt action would probably
be maintainable for longer, but the semi would be carried far more.

I heard the same rumors apparently...  Haven't seen anything more on 
these lately, which could just be me, or could indicate they're not in 
production any longer.

: It could be that there was a problem early on, and that they've 
: gotten it right by now -- but I'd want to hear from several
: people who'd been doing a lot of shooting with converted carbines
: before going for one myself.

I can see a few tremendous problems with such a weapon.  First, of course, 
is the durability issue.  The M1 carbine was never intended to take 
anything like the wear and tear of the .45 Win Mag.  Second, ammunition 
availability.  I can count on one hand the number of shops within a 
couple hours drive that have .45 Win Mag on the shelf.

Supposedly these conversions will also work with .45 ACP (I'd assume
using the extractor for keeping head space more or less correct), but I don't
 know how accurate or reliable that'd prove to be.

Third, even the .45 Win Mag has a very curved trajectory compared to a 
real rifle cartridge.  It'd still have a fair bit of energy down range, but
actually connecting with shots over 100 meters or so could be a real
problem; and all the power in the world does no good unless it hits
 something.

There're only a couple of serious contenders as far as cartridges go: 
5.56mm NATO or 7.62mm NATO (.223 Remington with heavy [62 grain]
bullets or .308 Winchester for you non-metric folks).  Military (and police)
 use more or less guarantees that there will always be _some_ means of 
obtaining ammunition.  Same holds for .45 ACP & 9mm NATO/Parabellum,
but pistol ammunition is of far less importance for hunting or fighting.

Lots of folks (myself included) are a bit skeptical about the 
effectiveness of the 5.56mm NATO in comparison to the .30 calibers,
but that's a decision you have to make for yourself.  There are plenty of 
(relatively) inexpensive 5.56mm auto-loaders such as the Mini-14, AR-15 
and clones, and so forth; usually much less expensive than the 7.62mm 
NATO auto-loaders. 

Though apparently the L1A1 "sporters" have come way down in price
recently.  At any rate, if you decide to go with 5.56mm NATO, get 
the 1 in 9 inch twist barrel on your rifle.  This'll let you use either
55 grain M193 ball (for the M16/M16A1) and 62 grain M855 ball.
 
(for the M16A2 and other NATO standardized rifles).  The 1 in 7 barrel of 
the issue M16A2 is intended for the M856 tracer bullet, which you'll have 
no real need for, and apparently erodes much faster than the 1 in 9 barrels.

The 1 in 12 barrel of the M16A1 and Mini-14 won't stabilize the M855
and other NATO standardized bullets, nor civilian ammo of more
than 55 grains or so in weight.  This handicaps long range performance.

Also remember that most civilian loadings are intended for varmint 
shooting, not big game hunting.  It may be illegal, but if you're trying 
to use 5.56mm on deer you need to use the military loadings, preferably 
the 62 grain M855 or equivalent.

7.62mm NATO has the advantage of using the common .308 inch ".30
caliber" bullet that's so popular in the US.  The civilian equivalent .308 
Winchester can be found in every gun shop or other place that sells 
ammunition.  The cartridge is far more tolerant of  mishandling, abuse 
and such than the 5.56mm.  It's easy to load, and components can be
scavenged easily from a great many other cartridges.  

It's very versatile; you can produce loads ranging from cast-lead 
wood cutters for shooting squirrels and birds to high powered stuff that'll 
handle elk or moose (or feral cattle and horses).  A small investment in 
some chamber adapters (and a Rubbermaid container to keep them dry and 
rust free) will let you use .32 ACP, .30 Carbine and some other rounds in 
a 7.62mm bolt action.

There's a fascinating section in _American Guerrilla in the Philippines_ 
by Ira Wolfert that describes the process of reloading .30-06 for the 
guerrillas' M1917 Enfields.  They used brass rod, filed down and swaged 
to bore size by hammering through a rifle bore, and loaded with scavenged 
Japanese explosive moderated with wood pulp.  It worked; but imagine 
trying to do that with a 5.56mm weapon, or a comparatively fragile 
auto-loader...

Pistol ammunition is of far less importance for hunting or fighting.

Lots of folks (myself included) are a bit skeptical about the effectiveness 
of the 5.56mm NATO in comparison to the .30 calibers, but that's a
decision you have to make for yourself.  There are plenty of  (relatively)
inexpensive 5.56mm auto-loaders such as the Mini-14, AR-15 
and clones, and so forth; usually much less expensive than the 7.62mm 
NATO auto-loaders.  Though apparently the L1A1 "sporters" have come
way down in price recently.

At any rate, if you decide to go with 5.56mm NATO, get the 1 in 9 inch 
twist barrel on your rifle.  This'll let you use either 55 grain M193 ball 
(for the M16/M16A1) and 62 grain M855 ball (for the M16A2 and 
other NATO standardized rifles).

The 1 in 7 barrel of  the issue M16A2 is intended for the M856 tracer
bullet, which you'll have no real need for, and apparently erodes much 
faster than the 1 in 9 barrels.

The 1 in 12 barrel of the M16A1 and Mini-14 won't stabilize the M855 
and other NATO standardized bullets, nor civilian ammo of more than 
55 grains or so in weight.  This handicaps long range performance.

Also remember that most civilian loadings are intended for varmint 
shooting, not big game hunting.  It may be illegal, but if you're trying 
to use 5.56mm on deer you need to use the military loadings, preferably 
the 62 grain M855 or equivalent.

7.62mm NATO has the advantage of using the common .308 inch "
.30 caliber" bullet that's so popular in the US.  The civilian equivalent
.308 Winchester can be found in every gun shop or other place that sells 
ammunition.  

I guess I'm going to be the "odd man out" on this one, but why bolt 
or lever action? For light weight, reasonable accuracy, durability, 
and (not often mentioned by most folks) parts availability in a 
survival situation, why not go with the tried-and-true AR-15/M16 
variants available? They are MORE than capable of performing in 
the manner you specified, and at the same time give you a much 
greater chance in a self-defense situation.

The buzzgun's little brother is an Ok poodle shooter, but much more 
expensive than many other options, and restricted in some places. It
could serve a defensive role in a fire-fight, being designed for close 
quarters jungle warfare, but as a hunting and general survival arm it 
is somewhat lacking. (Avoiding fire-fights should be a high priority
for a survival oriented person, so the poodle shooter's spray and
pray ability is of limited value.)

To get it into any semblance of an accurate shooter, much of its
rugged reliability has to be sacrificed. You have to tighten up
all those tolerances that allow it to shrug off field conditions.

They don't call it the Mattel flexiflyer for nothing. (And even in 
military tolerance it has problems in mud and snow that don't bother 
most .30 cal rifles.) And like many self-loaders, it's pretty picky 
about the ammo fed to it if you want to maintain reliable function. 

This is a handicap if you want to use specialty ammo (look at the 
variety available for a bolt, .30-06 for example, from Accelerators
to heavy near .300 Mag loads), or if you have to resort to scavenged 
ammo. You usually *can* chamber and fire a .30-06 that's been run over 
by a truck, but don't try it with .223, a dented case can yield very 
excessive pressures in that little cartridge.

While the parts situation is currently good, and there is an option
in extreme situations of augmenting that supply from military sources,
in many cases you may need to fabricate parts to repair the rifle.

If you compare it to a bolt rifle, the number, and intricacy, of the
parts in the AR-15 are much greater.

A basic rule in reliability engineering is that things with fewer
and more robust parts fail less often than things with many delicate
parts.

A bolt gun can even be used as a reloading press in an emergency.
You can put a rod down the barrel to act as a seating plug, and
hammer the shell into the chamber by beating on the bolt handle
with a rock. Try that with the AR-15. Or rather, *don't* try that
with an AR-15, its floating firing pin may allow it to fire without
being fully breeched if you start hammering on the forward assist.

End of  discussion on guns picked up on the Net a while back. 1995
